Brother Joe's Pizza

bret bitting 2 months ago

Love this place. Consistent every time. Pizza is excellent. Passes the flop test. Normally not a fan of different toppings on pizza, but everything they have is delicious. Philly cheesesteak, buffalo chicken, margarita. Highly recommended. Right next to giant on Hershey rd.

Hershey Kiss 5 months ago

We've been getting food from Brother Joes for several years now. The last time we ordered a chicken salad. The chicken was like saw dust. It couldn’t even be eaten. I’m not sure where the chicken is sourced from our they picked it off the floor😳, but it was really bad. We haven’t been back since.

Reviewer. 7 months ago

I went to this pizza spot yesterday and overall, it was a mixed experience. First off, the outside of the place looked nice and inviting. It’s located in a restaurant complex with several other spots nearby, which gives it a cool, walkable, door-to-door food area vibe. That part I genuinely liked. When I walked inside, though, the atmosphere felt a little off. There were several employees sitting around, while only two were actually behind the counter. I’m not sure if that’s normal for this place or if it just wasn’t busy at the time, but it was noticeable. On top of that, someone—whether it was a manager or another employee—was yelling at someone on a screen, which was uncomfortable to witness and definitely took away from the experience. I ordered two slices of pizza. The food itself was fine. It’s pizza, so there’s only so much to complain about, but it wasn’t anything special. Some bites had a noticeable aftertaste that wasn’t great, though it wasn’t bad enough to call the food horrible. Just average. One thing I did appreciate was the presentation. The box had a small message saying “thank you for your business,” which was a nice touch and showed some effort toward customer

Mj Shaw 11 months ago

Brother Joe’s Pizza is one of my favorite spots in the area! I’ve been coming here for the last 9 months, and the food is always delicious. I’ve tried the cheesesteak, chicken steak with cheese, and the chicken pizza — all of them were amazing! The customer service is super friendly and welcoming, and the place has a great family vibe. Whether you come with your family, kids, or friends, it’s the perfect place to relax and enjoy great food. Highly recommend!

Brian Meyer a year ago

I’ve been to this place four or five times in the past three weeks, and every visit has been outstanding. I originally came looking for a great buffalo chicken pizza, and I can honestly say it’s the best I’ve ever had—and I’ve tried a lot. The toppings are generous and high-quality, and you can tell the chicken is cooked with care. What really impressed me is that even with all those toppings, the crust stays perfectly crispy from edge to edge—never floppy. That’s a big deal for me. Beyond the buffalo chicken, they have an amazing variety of pizzas ready for customers, and every one I’ve seen looks just as thoughtfully made. The staff is always friendly and upbeat, and they even bring fresh slices out to people dining in, which makes the experience feel personal and welcoming. This place runs like a well-oiled machine, and it’s clear they’ve built a loyal following for a reason. If you love pizza, especially buffalo chicken, stop searching—this is the spot.